Dedicated to local collaborations and the best ingredients, this beloved shop serves handmade, small batch ice cream and non-dairy frozen desserts, with both seasonal and classic flavors available year around. Many of the available flavors are inspired by the owners’ Caribbean and Midwestern cultures, as well as Harlem.

A rotating portrait gallery of Harlem residents can be found on the walls of Sugar Hill Creamery. Hand drawn by Brooklyn-based artist Raúl Ayala, each featured resident represents the cultural diversity of Harlem.

Also at 3629 Broadway (between 149th St & 150th St), 1642 Lexington Avenue (between 103rd & 104th St) and Time Out Market NY.